BMO : TSX : C$62.50
BMO : NYSE
HOLD
Target: C$69.00
COMPANY DESCRIPTION:
With more than $525 billion in assets, Bank of Montreal, together with its subsidiaries, provides a broad range of retail banking, wealth management and investment banking products and solutions in North America and internationally. BMO operates approximately 1,600 bank branches and employs approximately 46,000 full time employees globally.
All amounts in C$ unless otherwise noted.
WEAK QUARTER: MARGINS AND EXPENSES
BMO reported Q2/13 adjusted EPS of $1.46, below our estimate and consensus of $1.49. EPS was up 1% YoY. Excluding the $66 million after tax recovery on the impaired credit portfolio acquired from M&I, EPS would have been $1.36. Relative to our estimate, stronger capital markets revenues were offset by lower insurance results, higher expenses, and a higher tax rate.
The Basel III CET ratio increased to 9.7% from 9.4%, reflecting earnings in the quarter and model refinements which lowered RWA. The bank bought back 4 million shares in the quarter. We believe BMO’s strong Tier 1 ratio and weaker earnings growth supports building in more aggressive share repurchase activity for 2013 and 2014. Insofar as capital allocation is concerned, we believe BMO is leaning more toward buy backs than acquisitions.
U.S. P&C earnings were up 9% YoY reflecting lower PCLs and expenses offset by weak top line growth (loan growth offset by NIM pressure). The 3% YoY decline in expenses reflects M&I synergies. On a US$ basis, total loans were up 0.4% QoQ (the second consecutive quarter of growth) as commercial loans were up 1.9 % QoQ and personal loans were down 1.2%. We expect synergies and good commercial loan growth (offset by NIM pressure) to drive mid- to- high-single-digit earnings growth.
Domestic P&C earnings were down 0.7% YoY, reflecting -2.3% operating leverage and additional NIM pressure. Expense growth was elevated, but consistent with commentary regarding the desire to continue to invest in the franchise. BMO’s issue with operating leverage does not appear to be expense control but rather the very weak top line growth. We do not believe revenue growth will accelerate in the near term largely because we expect margins to remain under pressure.
We continue to believe that BMO’s more aggressive posture in mortgages, while leading to strong mortgage growth this quarter (discussed below) is hurting the bank’s margin. Our 12-month target price of C$69.00 (down from C$70.00) is based on the stock trading at 10.8x our 2013E EPS, a 6% discount to the group multiple of 11.5x. We continue to rate BMO a HOLD. Our outlook on the stock is constrained by an expectation of below group average EPS growth driven by: a) higher PCLs as recoveries decline, b) NIM pressure, and c) weak operating leverage in domestic retail. We also expect BMO’s dividend growth to lag its peers.
Related articles
- U.S. Fed warns Bank of Montreal on anti-money laundering controls (business.financialpost.com)
- Toronto-Dominion Bank (amp2012.com)
- End-of-the-party feel to BMO results (business.financialpost.com)